Meccan and Medinan: how the surahs are classified, and why it matters
What makes a surah Meccan or Medinan, why the criterion scholars settled on is time rather than place, the features each group tends to show, and what a reader gains from knowing which is which.
Open any printed Quran and under each surah name sits a single word: Meccan or Medinan. It is one of the oldest classifications in the Quranic sciences, and less obvious than it looks — the disagreement is not over the answers but over the criterion.
Three criteria, and the one that prevailed
Scholars of this field name three ways of drawing the line:
- By time: Meccan is whatever was revealed before the hijra, Medinan whatever came after it — wherever it came down.
- By place: Meccan is what was revealed at Mecca and around it, Medinan what was revealed at Medina and around it.
- By audience: Meccan is what addresses the people of Mecca, Medinan what addresses the people of Medina.
Most of what has been written adopts the first, for one reason: it covers every verse without remainder. Every verse came either before the hijra or after it; there is no third case. The place criterion leaves out whatever was revealed on a journey, on a campaign, or on the Farewell Pilgrimage, and the audience criterion leaves out everything that opens with no address at all.
The example that settles it
The clearest test of which criterion is in use is a passage revealed at Arafat during the Farewell Pilgrimage:
This day I have perfected for you your religion and completed My favor upon you and have approved for you Islam as religion.
By place, that is Meccan. By time it is Medinan without dispute, revealed years after the hijra. The same goes for what came down on the road, at Tabuk, or at Jerusalem on the night journey. Meccan and Medinan are descriptions of when, not of where — that is the sense most of the discussion runs on.
The first revelation, and a Medinan law
The standard example of the Meccan is the first passage revealed at all:
Recite in the name of your Lord who created -
Created man from a clinging substance.
(Al-'Alaq 96:1, Al-'Alaq 96:2)
And the clearest examples of the Medinan are the legal verses, which came only once there was a community to govern — fasting, for instance:
O you who have believed, decreed upon you is fasting as it was decreed upon those before you that you may become righteous -
Features, not rules
What the handbooks list as differences between the two groups is a statement of what usually holds, not a law without exceptions — which is why the field itself states them as tendencies:
- Meccan passages lean towards the oneness of God, the resurrection and the reckoning, and argument with those who rejected the message; Medinan ones towards law, the affairs of a community, and dealings with the People of the Book and the hypocrites.
- Meccan verses tend to be short and strongly cadenced; Medinan ones longer, because they set out rules in detail.
- "O mankind" is frequent in the Meccan, "O you who have believed" in the Medinan.
- A surah containing a prostration, or the word kalla, is usually Meccan.
These are indications to lean on where no report survives, never proof on their own.
How it was known at all
Nothing in the Quran itself states that this surah is Meccan and that one Medinan. It rests on two things: transmission from the Companions and others who witnessed the revelation, which is the foundation; and, where no report survives, judgement from the context and subject matter of the surah. The second is what a commentator does when the first runs out. In Tafsir al-Mizan, at the head of Surah Ash-Sharh, Tabataba’i writes that the surah could be either Meccan or Medinan and that the context of its verses fits the Medinan better — saying plainly that the verdict rests on context, not on a decisive report.
Why a reader should care
It has at least three practical uses: knowing what came earlier and what later, which is the ground of any discussion of abrogation; reading an address against the situation of the people addressed when it came; and following how legislation arrived in stages rather than all at once. In that it sits next to the occasions of revelation — both return a verse to its moment.
Related: